C1 American · Dialogue 16
The Experiment That Fizzed
Hannah's chemistry experiment overflows, and her teacher helps her find out why and turn the mistake into a good lab report.
24 lines · Tap a line to hear it again
Dialogue
Mr. Okonkwo:Hannah, what happened over here? There's foam all over the lab bench.
Hannah:I honestly don't know, Mr. Okonkwo. I dropped the marble chips into the acid, and about five seconds later the whole thing fizzed up and overflowed. It was like a volcano.
Mr. Okonkwo:Okay, first things first. Are you all right? Did any of it touch your skin?
Hannah:No, I had my goggles and gloves on the whole time. Most of it ended up on my notebook.
Mr. Okonkwo:Good. Notebooks can be replaced. Let me wipe this down, and then let's look at your data together. What were you expecting to see?
Hannah:Well, the plan was to measure how much gas was produced every thirty seconds for five minutes. Everyone else at my table got a nice smooth curve. Mine was basically over in twenty seconds, and after that the numbers make no sense.
Mr. Okonkwo:Interesting. Which bottle of acid did you use?
Hannah:The one on the second shelf, by the window. It says hydrochloric acid on the label.
Mr. Okonkwo:Read me the rest of the label.
Hannah:Hydrochloric acid, two point zero... oh. Oh no. The worksheet says zero point five.
Mr. Okonkwo:There it is. Your acid was four times as concentrated as everyone else's. More acid particles in the same space means more collisions every second, so the reaction speeds up enormously. That's exactly what this experiment is supposed to show, just a little more dramatically than planned.
Hannah:So my results are useless. I'll have to do the whole thing again, and we only had this one lab period.
Mr. Okonkwo:Not so fast. Your results aren't useless. They're just not the results you were looking for. Some of the best lab reports I've ever graded were about experiments that went wrong.
Hannah:Really? How can a failed experiment get a good grade?
Mr. Okonkwo:Because science isn't about getting the "right" answer every time. It's about explaining what you observed. If you can show me why your reaction was so fast, using what we learned about particles, that's real understanding.
Hannah:So I should write about the mistake instead of hiding it?
Mr. Okonkwo:Exactly. Put it in your evaluation. Describe what went wrong, explain the effect it had, and suggest how to avoid it next time. Labeling the shelves more clearly might be a good start, by the way. That one's on me, not you.
Hannah:Could I compare my data with Jamal's? He used the right acid, and we had the same marble chips.
Mr. Okonkwo:That's a great idea. Two concentrations, everything else the same. You've accidentally designed a better experiment than the one on the worksheet.
Hannah:Ha. I'll take it. So when is the report due?
Mr. Okonkwo:It was due Wednesday, but I'll give you until Friday, since you'll need time to get Jamal's numbers and redraw your graph.
Hannah:Thank you so much. And sorry about the mess.
Mr. Okonkwo:Don't worry about it. Just promise me you'll read the whole label next time.
Hannah:I promise. Every single word.
Words in colour are explained in the glossary below.
Glossary
| Word | Meaning |
|---|---|
| foam/foʊm/ | a soft white mass of very small bubbles |
| fizzed/fɪzd/ | made lots of small bubbles and a soft hissing sound |
| overflowed/ˌoʊvərˈfloʊd/ | came over the top of a container because it was too full |
| goggles/ˈɡɑːɡəlz/ | special glasses that fit close to your face and protect your eyes |
| concentrated/ˈkɑːnsəntreɪtɪd/ | strong, because there is a lot of a substance and not much water |
| collisions/kəˈlɪʒənz/ | times when two things crash into each other |
| graded/ˈɡreɪdɪd/ | read and gave a score to a piece of school work |
| evaluation/ɪˌvæljuˈeɪʃən/ | the part of a report where you judge how well something worked and what was wrong |
Tests
Found this text useful? Share it with a friend or your class.