1Bentuk: modal + have + past participle
Untuk membuat dugaan tentang masa lalu, kata kerja modalnya tetap dalam bentuk yang sama, lalu kita tambahkan have + past participle (bentuk ketiga kata kerja: gone, seen, forgotten, left). Modalnya tidak pernah berubah: tidak ada bentuk 'musted' atau 'had must'. Kata have juga tidak pernah berubah — tetap have, bahkan dengan he, she, dan it, karena letaknya sesudah kata kerja modal.
| Modal | Contoh |
|---|---|
| must have | She must have forgotten about the meeting. |
| may have | They may have taken the wrong road. |
| might have | He might have left his phone at home. |
| could have | The letter could have got lost in the post. |
| can't have | You can't have finished already! |
| couldn't have | She couldn't have known about the party. |
2Must have: hampir pasti ya
Kita memakai must have jika bukti membuat kita hampir yakin bahwa sesuatu memang terjadi. Di sini must tidak berarti kewajiban — ini adalah kesimpulan logis. Kita tidak bisa 100% yakin karena kita tidak melihatnya sendiri, tetapi tidak ada penjelasan lain yang masuk akal.
- ✓
The streets are wet. It must have rained in the night.
- ✓
You got 98% in the exam? You must have worked really hard.
- ✓
Ben isn't at his desk and his coat has gone. He must have gone home.
- ✓
I can't find my keys. I must have left them at the office.
3Can't have / couldn't have: hampir pasti tidak
Kebalikan dari must have adalah can't have atau couldn't have. Kita memakainya jika bukti membuat kita hampir yakin bahwa sesuatu tidak terjadi atau mustahil terjadi. Kedua bentuk ini artinya hampir sama; couldn't have sedikit lebih sering dipakai dalam cerita dan kalimat tidak langsung.
- ✓
He can't have seen us — he didn't even wave.
- ✓
You can't have spent all your money already! You only got it yesterday.
- ✓
She couldn't have taken the train: there were no trains because of the strike.
- ✓
That can't have been Anna you saw. She's in Australia this month.
4May have / might have / could have: mungkin
Jika kita menganggap sesuatu mungkin terjadi tetapi kita tidak yakin, kita memakai may have, might have, atau could have. Ketiganya artinya sangat mirip. May have bisa terdengar sedikit lebih formal; might have paling sering dipakai dalam percakapan; could have menunjukkan bahwa sesuatu mungkin saja terjadi.
- ✓
Lucy is late. She might have missed the bus.
- ✓
I'm not sure where I put the receipt. I may have thrown it away.
- ✓
Someone could have taken your umbrella by mistake.
- ✓
The email might have gone into your spam folder.
Bentuk negatif might not have dan may not have berarti 'mungkin hal itu tidak terjadi'. Perhatikan bahwa artinya sangat berbeda dengan can't have, yang berarti 'saya yakin hal itu tidak terjadi'.
| Kalimat | Arti |
|---|---|
| She might not have heard the doorbell. | Mungkin dia tidak mendengarnya. |
| She can't have heard the doorbell. | Saya yakin dia tidak mendengarnya. |
5Skala keyakinan
Akan membantu jika kamu membayangkan modal-modal ini pada sebuah skala dari 'hampir pasti ya' sampai 'hampir pasti tidak'. Saat membuat dugaan, tentukan dulu seberapa yakin kamu, lalu pilih modalnya.
| Seberapa yakin? | Modal | Contoh |
|---|---|---|
| Sekitar 95% ya | must have | The lights are off. They must have gone to bed. |
| Sekitar 50% — mungkin | may / might / could have | They might have gone to bed. |
| Sekitar 50% — mungkin tidak | may not / might not have | They might not have gone to bed yet. |
| Sekitar 95% tidak | can't / couldn't have | They can't have gone to bed — it's only eight o'clock. |
6Bentuk continuous: must have been doing
Jika dugaan itu tentang tindakan yang sedang berlangsung pada suatu saat di masa lalu (bukan tindakan yang sudah selesai), kita memakai bentuk continuous: modal + have been + -ing. Bandingkan: She must have slept (tindakan yang sudah selesai) dan She must have been sleeping (dia sedang tidur pada saat itu).
- ✓
I phoned you at midnight but you didn't answer. You must have been sleeping.
- ✓
He can't have been listening — he didn't understand a single question.
- ✓
She looked very relaxed. She might have been reading a good book.
- ✓
The driver could have been using his phone when the accident happened.
| Bentuk simple (selesai) | Bentuk continuous (sedang berlangsung) |
|---|---|
| He must have finished work early. | He must have been working when you called. |
| They might have seen the film. | They might have been watching a film. |
7Dugaan tentang masa kini atau masa lalu?
Kamu sudah mengenal bentuk masa kini: She must be tired. He can't be at home. They might be busy. Untuk memindahkan dugaan ke masa lalu, ubah infinitifnya (be, know, work) menjadi perfect infinitive (have been, have known, have worked). Modalnya sendiri tetap sama.
| Dugaan tentang masa kini | Dugaan tentang masa lalu |
|---|---|
| She must be at work. (sekarang) | She must have been at work. (kemarin) |
| He can't know the answer. | He can't have known the answer. |
| They might be lost. | They might have got lost. |
| You must be joking! | You must have been joking! |
| She could be sleeping. | She could have been sleeping. |
- ✓
Tom isn't answering. He must be in a meeting. (now)
- ✓
Tom didn't answer this morning. He must have been in a meeting. (in the past)
8Could have: dugaan atau kesempatan yang terlewat?
Hati-hati: could have punya dua arti. Dalam pelajaran ini artinya 'mungkin hal itu terjadi' (sebuah dugaan). Could have juga bisa berarti 'hal itu mungkin terjadi, tetapi ternyata tidak terjadi' (kesempatan yang terlewat atau nyaris celaka). Konteks menunjukkan arti mana yang dimaksud.
| Kalimat | Arti |
|---|---|
| Where's my wallet? I could have dropped it in the taxi. | Dugaan: mungkin saya menjatuhkannya. |
| You could have hurt yourself! Be more careful. | Kemungkinan yang tidak terjadi: kamu bisa saja terluka, tetapi ternyata tidak. |