Eenglish-tests.com
C1

Unreal past and the subjunctive

English uses past verb forms not only for the past but also for situations that are imaginary, unlikely or only wished for. This is the unreal past: It's time we left (now). I'd rather you didn't tell anyone (in the future). He talks as if he were an expert (but he isn't). Closely related is the subjunctive, a rare form you will meet in formal English: The doctor recommended that she rest for a week. It is essential that every passenger carry a passport. On this page you will review the unreal past from B2, then go further with would rather and would sooner, as if and as though, suppose and imagine, the choice between were and was, the mandative subjunctive after verbs like insist and suggest, and fixed expressions such as be that as it may.

1Review: the unreal past

In some structures, a past tense does not describe past time. It describes distance from reality: the situation is imaginary, unlikely or desired but not true. You already know this from the second conditional and from wish. The rule is simple: to talk about an unreal present or future, use the past simple; to talk about an unreal past, use the past perfect. The verb moves 'one step back'.

StructureUnreal present / futureUnreal past
if (second / third)If I had more time…If I had had more time…
wish / if onlyI wish I knew the answer.I wish I had known the answer.
would ratherI'd rather you stayed.I'd rather you hadn't left.
as if / as thoughHe talks as if he owned the place.She looked as if she had seen a ghost.
suppose / imagineSuppose you lost your job…Suppose you had lost your job…

Why does English do this? The past tense naturally expresses distance: distance in time (yesterday), distance from reality (an imaginary situation) and social distance (politeness: I wondered if you could help me). All three uses share the same idea of 'not here, not now, not real'. Understanding this makes the structures on this page much easier to remember.

2It's time, it's high time, it's about time

It's time + subject + past simple means that something should happen now or should already have happened. It often carries a note of impatience or gentle criticism, especially with high time and about time. The past form has a present meaning. When we simply mean 'the right moment has come', without any criticism, we use It's time + to-infinitive or It's time for + someone + to-infinitive.

StructureExample
It's time + to + base verb (neutral)It's time to start the meeting.
It's time for + noun + to + base verb (neutral)It's time for the children to go to bed.
It's time + subject + past simple (should happen now)It's time we left — the last train goes at eleven.
It's high time + subject + past simple (stronger)It's high time the council repaired this road.
It's about time + subject + past simple (impatient)It's about time you replied to that email!
  • ✓

    It's high time governments took plastic pollution seriously.

  • ✓

    It's about time the trains ran on time on this line.

  • ✓

    It's time I was going — thanks for a lovely evening.

    the past continuous is also possible

  • ✗

    It's time we start the project.

    After It's time + subject, use the past: It's time we started.

3Would rather and would sooner

Would rather (I'd rather) and the slightly less common would sooner both mean 'would prefer'. They follow two patterns. When the subject is the same person, use the base verb without to. When we want another person or thing to do something, we use a new subject + past simple for the present or future, and past perfect for the past. This second pattern is often a polite way of making a request or expressing disapproval.

PatternExample
same subject + base verbI'd rather work from home tomorrow.
same subject + base verb + than + base verbI'd sooner walk than wait an hour for a bus.
another subject + past simple (present / future)I'd rather you didn't mention it to anyone.
another subject + past perfect (past)I'd rather they hadn't cancelled the concert.
questionWould you rather I came back later?
  • ✓

    My manager would rather we sent the report by Thursday.

  • ✓

    I'd sooner you told me the truth, even if it's difficult.

  • ✓

    We'd rather you hadn't posted those photos without asking.

  • ✗

    I'd rather to stay at home tonight.

    No to: I'd rather stay at home.

4As if and as though

As if and as though (they mean the same) compare a situation with something else. The tense depends on what the speaker believes. If the comparison is probably true, use normal tenses: It looks as if it's going to rain (there are dark clouds). If the comparison is unreal or unlikely, use the unreal past: He talks as if he knew everything (he doesn't). For an unreal comparison with an earlier time, use the past perfect.

MeaningExample
real / probable → normal tenseYou look as if you need a rest. (you probably do)
unreal, same time → past simpleHe spends money as if he were a millionaire. (he isn't)
unreal, earlier time → past perfectShe described the city as if she had lived there for years. (she hadn't)
after a past main verb (real)It felt as if the day would never end.

Common verbs before as if are look, seem, sound, feel, act, behave and talk. In everyday British English, like is often used instead of as if (It looks like it's going to rain), but in formal writing as if or as though is preferred. As if on its own can also be an informal exclamation meaning 'that's impossible': She'll lend you her car? As if!

  • ✓

    The new intern behaves as though she were the head of the department.

  • ✓

    It sounds as if the negotiations are going well. (real: the news is good)

  • ✓

    He looked at me as if I had said something shocking.

  • ✓

    The forest was so quiet it felt as though time had stopped.

5Suppose, supposing, imagine, what if

These expressions invite the listener to consider a situation. Like if, they can be followed by a real tense (a possible situation) or by the unreal past (a more hypothetical one). The choice shows how likely the speaker thinks the situation is. For the past, use the past perfect. I'd prefer it if and I'd like it if also take the unreal past.

ExampleMeaning
Suppose the meeting is cancelled — what then?quite possible
Suppose the meeting were cancelled — what would we do?less likely, more hypothetical
Imagine you had a whole year off. Where would you go?imaginary present
What if we had taken the earlier train?imaginary past
I'd prefer it if you didn't call after ten.polite request
  • ✓

    Supposing the experiment failed, would the funding be withdrawn?

  • ✓

    Imagine you could speak every language in the world.

  • ✓

    What if nobody had invented the printing press?

6Were or was?

In unreal structures, were is sometimes used for all persons, including I, he, she and it: If I were you… I wish it were Friday. He acts as if he were in charge. This were is a remnant of the old past subjunctive. In modern British English, was is also very common with I, he, she and it in informal speech. Both are correct, but they carry a difference in register.

Formal / written (preferred)Informal / spoken (also correct)
If I were you, I would apologise.If I was you, I'd say sorry.
I wish it were warmer.I wish it was warmer.
She acts as if she were the boss.She acts like she was the boss.
Were I to resign… (inversion)— (only were is possible)

Remember two limits. First, in the inverted forms (Were I to…, Were it not for…) only were is possible. Second, in fixed phrases like If I were you and as it were (= so to speak), were is much more usual. In exams and formal writing, it is safest to use were.

7The subjunctive after insist, suggest, recommend…

The mandative subjunctive is a special verb form used after words expressing demands, recommendations, proposals and necessity. It looks exactly like the base form of the verb, for every person and every tense: the verb has no -s in the third person, and be stays be. Because the base form never changes, the subjunctive does not follow the tense of the main verb. The negative is not + base verb, with no do.

verb / adjective + that + subject + base verb (no -s, no tense change)
TriggerExample
insist, demand, requestThe customer insisted that the manager apologise in person.
suggest, propose, recommendThe doctor recommended that she rest for a week.
ask, advise, urge (formal)We urge that the council reconsider its decision.
It is essential / vital / crucial that…It is essential that every passenger carry a valid passport.
It is important / necessary / imperative that…It is important that he be told before the announcement.
negative: not + base verbThe committee proposed that the fee not be increased.

The subjunctive is used in both British and American English, but British speakers also often use should + base verb (The doctor recommended that she should rest), and in informal British English a normal tense is common too (The doctor recommended that she rests). In formal writing and in exams, the subjunctive or should are the safest choices. Note that suggest and recommend can also take an -ing form without a new subject: She suggested taking a taxi.

  • ✓

    The teacher insisted that every student hand in the essay by Friday.

  • ✓

    It is vital that the vaccine be stored at a low temperature.

  • ✓

    The report recommends that the factory reduce its water use by 20 per cent.

  • ✓

    They suggested that she should apply for the scholarship.

    British alternative with should

  • ✗

    I suggest you to take the earlier train.

    Suggest is not followed by object + to-infinitive. Say: I suggest (that) you take…

8Fixed subjunctive expressions

A few fixed expressions keep the old subjunctive form. They cannot be changed, and many sound formal, literary or slightly old-fashioned, but you will meet them in speeches, articles and books. Some are also used humorously in conversation.

ExpressionMeaning and example
Be that as it mayeven so: Be that as it may, we still need a decision today.
Come what maywhatever happens: Come what may, I'll be at your graduation.
If need beif necessary: We can work at the weekend, if need be.
Suffice it to sayI'll only say this: Suffice it to say, the trip didn't go to plan.
So be itI accept it: If that's your decision, so be it.
as it wereso to speak: She is, as it were, the heart of the team.
Long live…a wish for long life or success: Long live the King!
Heaven forbidI really hope not: Heaven forbid that we should miss the last ferry!

9Register: formal and informal

Almost every structure on this page has a neutral or informal equivalent. Choosing between them depends on the reader. The subjunctive, were for all persons, would sooner and as though tend to appear in formal writing, reports and official documents. In conversation, British people often choose should, was, like and simpler verbs such as want or prefer.

Informal / neutralFormal
It looks like it's going to rain.It appears as though it is going to rain.
I wish I was taller.I wish I were taller.
They said he should apologise.They demanded that he apologise.
Everyone has to wear a helmet.It is essential that everyone wear a helmet.
Please don't call after ten.I would rather you did not call after ten.

10Typical mistakes of advanced learners

Russian and Ukrainian express these meanings with a single conditional particle and a past form, or with an infinitive after verbs like 'suggest' and 'insist'. As a result, learners often put would or the present tense after it's time and would rather, use object + to-infinitive after suggest, and forget to remove the -s in the subjunctive.

Unreal past and the subjunctive: tests

2 free tests and 8 Premium tests.

GameFix the mistake: Unreal past and the subjunctiveFind the mistake in each sentence and choose the right word.Play →

Found this lesson useful? Share it with a friend or your class.