1Quick review: -ing and past participle
A defining relative clause can often be shortened when the relative pronoun is the subject of the clause. We delete the pronoun and either delete the verb be or change the verb into a participle. The present participle (-ing) keeps an active meaning; the past participle keeps a passive meaning. The reduced clause follows the noun directly, with no commas, exactly where the full clause would be.
Full clause → reduced clause
| Full relative clause | Reduced relative clause |
|---|---|
| Delegates who are attending the conference should register online. | Delegates attending the conference should register online. |
| Anyone who wishes to comment may do so in writing. | Anyone wishing to comment may do so in writing. |
| The data that were collected last year are still being analysed. | The data collected last year are still being analysed. |
| Most of the goods that are sold online are delivered within days. | Most of the goods sold online are delivered within days. |
Notice what does not change: the meaning, the position of the clause and the tense, which the reader takes from the context. 'The data collected last year' is understood as past because of 'last year'; 'goods sold online' is understood as a general fact. The participle itself carries no tense, which is exactly why it is so flexible.
- ✓
Researchers working on the project have published their first results.
- ✓
The species found only on this island is now protected by law.
- ✓
Passengers arriving from outside the UK must complete a short form.
- ✓
The figures quoted in the article were later corrected.
2When you can and cannot reduce
Reduction is only possible when the relative pronoun is the subject of its clause. If the pronoun is the object, there is nothing to turn into a participle; instead, you can simply leave the pronoun out (a so-called zero relative), but the subject and the verb stay. This distinction matters, because many advanced learners try to 'reduce' object clauses and produce sentences that are impossible.
| Pronoun is the subject → reduce | Pronoun is the object → leave out the pronoun only |
|---|---|
| the report that was published today → the report published today | the report that we published today → the report we published today |
| a woman who runs a charity → a woman running a charity | a woman whom I met at a charity event → a woman I met at a charity event |
The second restriction concerns the -ing form. An -ing reduced clause describes an action in progress or a general, ongoing situation. It is not used for a single, completed action in the past, and it is not normally used to replace a clause with a modal verb or a perfect form that carries an important meaning. In those cases, keep the full relative clause.
- ✓
The man sitting opposite me was reading a newspaper.
in progress at that moment
- ✓
People living near the airport complain about the noise.
a general situation
- ✗
The student winning the prize last year now works in Geneva.
a single finished action → the student who won the prize last year
- ✓
Those who can help should stay behind.
modal can → no reduction is possible
3-ing with state verbs: containing, belonging, involving
State verbs such as contain, belong, involve, require, consist, resemble, depend and own are not normally used in continuous tenses: we say 'a box which contains documents', not 'which is containing'. Surprisingly, these verbs are perfectly natural in reduced -ing clauses. Here the -ing form does not mean 'in progress'; it simply replaces a present simple verb. This is one of the most useful patterns in formal writing.
| Full clause (present simple) | Reduced clause |
|---|---|
| a file that contains confidential data | a file containing confidential data |
| land that belongs to the council | land belonging to the council |
| a task which requires great patience | a task requiring great patience |
| a diet that consists mainly of vegetables | a diet consisting mainly of vegetables |
| decisions which involve large sums of money | decisions involving large sums of money |
- ✓
Investigators found a suitcase containing old letters and photographs.
- ✓
Any problems relating to your account should be reported to customer services.
- ✓
The museum owns a painting resembling an early Turner.
- ✓
Families depending on a single income were hit hardest by the price rises.
4Passive forms: built, being built, to be built
A past participle on its own usually describes a finished action or a general state. To show that a passive action is in progress right now, we use being + past participle. To show that it is planned or will happen in the future, we use to be + past participle. These three forms allow very precise descriptions in news reports and official documents.
| Form | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| past participle | done before now, or a general fact | The bridge built in 1890 is still in use. |
| being + past participle | in progress now (passive continuous) | The bridge being built across the river will open next spring. |
| to be + past participle | planned for the future | The bridge to be built next year has already caused controversy. |
- ✓
The proposals being discussed today could change the way schools are funded.
= which are being discussed
- ✓
The issues to be addressed at the summit include climate and trade.
= which will be addressed
- ✓
The vaccine being tested in this trial was developed in Oxford.
- ✓
All the documents to be signed are on your desk.
- ✓
The road repaired last month already has cracks in it.
past participle alone → a finished action
5The first to arrive: infinitive clauses
After ordinal numbers (the first, the second), after superlatives and after the words the last, the next and the only, English prefers a to-infinitive instead of a relative clause. The infinitive has an active meaning ('who did it') unless we use the passive infinitive to be + past participle. This pattern is very common in news and history: the first woman to win, the youngest player to score, the only country to agree.
| Full relative clause | Infinitive clause |
|---|---|
| She was the first woman who won the prize twice. | She was the first woman to win the prize twice. |
| He was the last person who left the building. | He was the last person to leave the building. |
| Norway was the only country that voted against. | Norway was the only country to vote against. |
| She is the youngest player who has ever scored for the club. | She is the youngest player ever to score for the club. |
| It was the first planet that was discovered with a telescope. | It was the first planet to be discovered with a telescope. |
- ✓
Valentina Tereshkova was the first woman to travel into space.
- ✓
The next speaker to address the conference is a professor from Edinburgh.
- ✓
He was the only student to be offered a full scholarship.
- ✓
The last train to leave London tonight departs at 23:40.
- ✗
She was the first who arrived at the party.
→ She was the first to arrive at the party.
Notice that the infinitive works for completed past actions too: 'the first to arrive' can mean 'the first person who arrived'. This is different from the -ing form, which cannot describe a single finished action. So we say the first person to climb Everest, never ✗ the first person climbing Everest.
6A place to stay, the person to ask: infinitives with modal meaning
A to-infinitive after a noun can also replace a relative clause with a modal meaning: can, could, should or must. In this case, the noun is usually the object of the infinitive: a book to read = a book that you can read; the person to ask = the person you should ask. When we need to mention who does the action, we add for + object before the infinitive.
| Full relative clause | Infinitive clause |
|---|---|
| We need somewhere where we can stay. | We need somewhere to stay. |
| She's the person whom you should ask. | She's the person to ask. |
| There are several forms that must be completed. | There are several forms to be completed. |
| Here is a list of books that the students can read. | Here is a list of books for the students to read. |
- ✓
Edinburgh in August is a wonderful city to visit, but book early.
- ✓
That's not a decision to take lightly.
- ✓
There's a lot of research to be done before we can draw any conclusions.
- ✓
The council has provided a space for young people to meet after school.
- ✓
If you have a problem with your visa, the office to contact is the one on the third floor.
7The people involved, the room upstairs: short phrases after nouns
Sometimes a relative clause with be can be reduced to just an adjective phrase, a prepositional phrase or an adverb. Most adjectives go before the noun, but a small group goes after it, especially in formal English: the people present, the person responsible, the issues involved, the members concerned. A longer adjective phrase also follows the noun: a solution acceptable to everyone.
| Full relative clause | Reduced phrase |
|---|---|
| Everyone who was present agreed. | Everyone present agreed. |
| the person who is responsible for safety | the person responsible for safety |
| the students who are concerned | the students concerned |
| a compromise that is acceptable to both sides | a compromise acceptable to both sides |
| the flat that is upstairs | the flat upstairs |
| the woman who is in the blue coat | the woman in the blue coat |
Some of these words change their meaning depending on their position. Before the noun, 'concerned' means 'worried'; after the noun, it means 'affected' or 'that we are talking about'. 'The present members' are the current members; 'the members present' are the ones who are in the room now. Learn these pairs carefully.
Before or after the noun?
| Before the noun | After the noun |
|---|---|
| concerned parents = worried parents | the parents concerned = the parents affected |
| the present situation = the current situation | the people present = the people in the room |
| a responsible person = sensible, reliable | the person responsible = the one who did it or is in charge |
| an involved explanation = complicated | the people involved = taking part |
- ✓
The headteacher has written to all the families concerned.
- ✓
Of the 200 members present, only six voted against the motion.
- ✓
Police are trying to find the person responsible for the damage.
- ✓
We are looking for a venue large enough for 300 guests.
8Reduced non-defining clauses and apposition
Non-defining relative clauses, the ones with commas, can also be reduced. The participle or adjective phrase stays between commas, just like the full clause. A special case is apposition: a noun phrase placed next to another noun phrase to describe it. It is a reduced form of 'who is / which is + noun' and is extremely common in journalism and biographies.
| Full non-defining clause | Reduced form |
|---|---|
| The castle, which was built in the 12th century, attracts thousands of visitors. | The castle, built in the 12th century, attracts thousands of visitors. |
| The new policy, which aims to cut waste, comes into force in May. | The new policy, aiming to cut waste, comes into force in May. |
| Marie Curie, who was a physicist and chemist, won two Nobel Prizes. | Marie Curie, a physicist and chemist, won two Nobel Prizes. |
| The report, which is now available online, makes worrying reading. | The report, now available online, makes worrying reading. |
- ✓
The Shard, completed in 2012, is the tallest building in the UK.
- ✓
Dr Patel, a specialist in tropical diseases, will give the opening lecture.
- ✓
The festival, now in its 40th year, has become a major tourist attraction.
- ✓
The bill, opposed by several members of the government, was passed by a narrow majority.
9Register: formal and informal
Reduced relative clauses exist in all styles, but they are far more frequent in writing. Academic articles, reports, news stories, instructions and official notices use them constantly because they pack a lot of information into a short noun phrase. In relaxed conversation, people tend to use full clauses with who, that or a zero relative, or they split the information into two sentences. Formal notices often use the -ing form with verbs such as wish, require, seek and intend.
| Informal / spoken | Formal / written |
|---|---|
| If you want a refund, you need to fill in this form. | Customers wishing to obtain a refund must complete this form. |
| The guy who's in charge of the project left last week. | The person responsible for the project left last week. |
| They've found some bones. They're about 3,000 years old. | Archaeologists have found bones dating back 3,000 years. |
| She was the first one who got there. | She was the first to arrive. |
| There's loads we still have to do. | Much work remains to be done. |
10Typical mistakes of advanced learners
Speakers of Russian, Ukrainian and other Slavic languages have rich participle systems in their own languages, and that is both a help and a trap. In Slavic languages, a long participle phrase can go before the noun ('the by him written book'); in English, a participle with any extra words must follow the noun. Slavic past active participles also have no direct English equivalent, so they cannot be translated with -ing.