1What are ellipsis and substitution?
Both devices exist for the same reason: to avoid repetition when the meaning can easily be recovered from the context. With ellipsis, words are simply omitted and the listener fills the gap mentally. With substitution, a short 'pro-form' takes the place of a longer phrase. The two often work together in the same exchange.
| Full version (repetitive) | Natural version |
|---|---|
| I can't swim, but my sister can swim. | I can't swim, but my sister can. (ellipsis) |
| 'Is it going to rain?' 'I think it is going to rain.' | 'Is it going to rain?' 'I think so.' (substitution) |
| I don't need a new phone, but Sam needs a new phone. | I don't need a new phone, but Sam needs one. (substitution) |
| 'Would you like to join us?' 'I'd love to join you.' | 'Would you like to join us?' 'I'd love to.' (ellipsis) |
You have already met the basics at lower levels: short answers (Yes, I have. No, she isn't.), question tags, and agreeing with so and neither (So do I. Neither have we.). All of these are forms of ellipsis: the auxiliary stays and the rest of the verb phrase disappears. At C1 you need to control the full system, including the less obvious cases and the differences between spoken and written English.
2Ellipsis after auxiliaries and modals
When a verb phrase is repeated, we keep only the first auxiliary or modal verb and drop everything after it. The auxiliary must match the tense and the subject of the new clause, so it is often different from the auxiliary in the first clause. If the first clause has no auxiliary (Present Simple or Past Simple), we use do, does or did.
- ✓
I haven't finished the report yet, but Anna has.
- ✓
Most of the team voted for the proposal, although a few didn't.
- ✓
She said she would phone the airline, and she did.
- ✓
I wasn't expecting the results to be so good, but my supervisor was.
- ✓
We can't guarantee delivery by Friday, but we will if we possibly can.
- ✓
'You should apply for that scholarship.' 'I know I should.'
With perfect and continuous forms we can keep more than one auxiliary. Both versions are correct; keeping two auxiliaries is slightly more emphatic or precise.
| Question | Possible replies |
|---|---|
| Has the parcel arrived? | It may have. / It may have done. (British) |
| Has she been told about the change? | She should have been. / She should have. |
| Will the work be finished by June? | It should be. / It should. |
3Keeping to: I'd like to, I didn't mean to
When a to-infinitive has already been mentioned, we can leave out the verb but we usually keep the word to. This is very common after want, would like, would love, hope, try, mean, need, have, ought, used, be able, be going and similar verbs. Without to, the sentence sounds incomplete in English, even though the equivalent in many other languages is perfectly normal.
- ✓
'Are you coming to the leaving party?' 'I'd love to, but I'm working that evening.'
- ✓
You don't have to give a speech if you don't want to.
- ✓
'You've deleted the whole file!' 'Sorry — I didn't mean to.'
- ✓
I wanted to study medicine, but my grades weren't high enough for me to be able to.
- ✓
She doesn't play the violin much now, but she used to.
- ✓
'Have you booked the tickets?' 'No, but I'm going to this evening.'
If the omitted verb is be, or the verb is in the perfect, we keep be or have after to: 'Is she qualified?' 'She claims to be.' 'Did he check the figures?' 'He was supposed to have.' Leaving out be here would make the sentence ungrammatical.
4Substitution with so and not: I hope so, I'm afraid not
After certain verbs of thinking and speaking, we replace a whole that-clause with so (positive) or not (negative). 'Will the flight be on time?' 'I think so.' means 'I think that the flight will be on time.' This is one of the most frequent patterns in spoken English.
Verbs used with so and not
| Positive | Negative |
|---|---|
| I think so. | I don't think so. (I think not is formal) |
| I expect so. | I don't expect so. / I expect not. |
| I suppose so. | I don't suppose so. / I suppose not. |
| I believe so. | I don't believe so. / I believe not. (formal) |
| I imagine so. | I don't imagine so. / I imagine not. |
| I hope so. | I hope not. (never I don't hope so) |
| I'm afraid so. | I'm afraid not. (never I'm not afraid so) |
| It seems / appears so. | It seems / appears not. |
With think, expect, suppose, believe and imagine, the negative is normally made with don't + verb + so; the version with not is more formal (I think not, I believe not), although I expect not and I suppose not are also common in everyday British speech. With hope and be afraid, only the not version is possible. I'm afraid so and I'm afraid not are polite ways of giving bad news: 'Is the museum closed today?' 'I'm afraid so.' (Yes, unfortunately.)
- ✓
'Will we need our passports?' 'I imagine so — it's an international flight.'
- ✓
'Is the shop open on bank holidays?' 'I don't think so.'
- ✓
'Do we have to resubmit the whole application?' 'I'm afraid so.'
- ✓
'Will the storm cause any damage?' 'Let's hope not.'
- ✓
'Has the decision been made yet?' 'It appears not.'
5Where so and not are not possible
Not every verb of thinking can take so. With know, be sure, be certain and agree, we either use the verb alone or repeat a short clause with an auxiliary. Using so after them is a typical error even at advanced level.
| Wrong | Right |
|---|---|
| 'The deadline's tomorrow.' 'I know so.' | 'The deadline's tomorrow.' 'I know.' / 'I know it is.' |
| 'Will she pass?' 'I'm sure so.' | 'Will she pass?' 'I'm sure she will.' |
| 'Is he right?' 'I agree so.' | 'Is he right?' 'I agree.' / 'I think so.' |
So can also come at the beginning of a short reply with verbs of hearing and appearing. This pattern shows that the information is not new to you, or that you are reporting something you have been told: 'The new manager starts on Monday.' 'So I hear.' / 'So I've been told.' / 'So it seems.'
6Substituting nouns: one and ones
To avoid repeating a countable noun, we replace it with one (singular) or ones (plural). One/ones usually follows an adjective, the, this/that, which, each, every or another, or comes before a relative clause or prepositional phrase. When the meaning is 'a/an + noun', one alone is enough.
- ✓
These trainers are too small. Have you got any bigger ones?
- ✓
My laptop is much slower than the one you bought last year.
- ✓
'Which flat did you choose?' 'The one with the balcony.'
- ✓
I left my umbrella on the bus, so I'll have to buy one.
- ✓
Of all the proposals we received, this one is the most realistic.
When not to use one/ones
| Rule | Example |
|---|---|
| Not with uncountable nouns: just leave the noun out. | I prefer brown bread to white. (not white one) |
| Not after a number: just use the number. | I needed some apples, so I bought three. (not three ones) |
| Not for an indefinite plural: use some or any. | I've run out of pens. Can you lend me some? (not ones) |
| Usually not after a possessive: use mine, yours, Anna's. | This isn't my coat — it's Anna's. (not Anna's one) |
7Substituting verb phrases: do so, do it, do that
A verb phrase can be replaced by do so, do it or do that. They are close in meaning but differ in register and focus. Do so is neutral to formal and is the standard choice in reports, instructions and academic writing. Do it and do that are more conversational; do that often adds emphasis or contrast, and both usually refer to a deliberate, specific action.
- ✓
The minister promised to publish the report, and she did so the following week.
- ✓
Passengers who wish to change their booking may do so online.
- ✓
Applicants are advised to apply early, and those who do so will receive a reply within ten days.
- ✓
'Someone needs to tell him the news.' 'I'll do it.'
- ✓
'He just walked out of the meeting.' 'Why did he do that?'
Do so normally replaces actions, not states. We cannot say 'She knows the answer and I do so too'; instead we use the auxiliary: She knows the answer, and so do I / and I do too.
8Ellipsis in speech and in writing
In informal conversation, we often leave out words at the beginning of a sentence: the subject, the auxiliary, or both, and sometimes an article. This 'situational ellipsis' is only possible when the missing words are obvious. It is typical of chat, text messages and emails between friends, but should be avoided in formal writing.
| Informal (ellipsis) | Full form |
|---|---|
| Sounds great! | That sounds great! |
| Seen Tom anywhere? | Have you seen Tom anywhere? |
| Want a lift to the station? | Do you want a lift to the station? |
| Don't know, sorry. | I don't know, sorry. |
| Coming? | Are you coming? |
| Told you so! | I told you so! |
Written English uses a different kind of ellipsis, inside a sentence. When two clauses are joined with and, but or or, a repeated subject, auxiliary or verb can be left out. Omitting the verb in the second clause (called gapping) sounds particularly formal and elegant.
- ✓
The researchers collected the samples and (they) analysed them in the laboratory.
- ✓
Some delegates travelled by train; others, by coach.
- ✓
The first group was given written instructions, the second, a short video.
- ✓
Someone has borrowed my charger, but I've no idea who.
9Formal and informal register
Ellipsis and substitution occur in all registers, but the choice of device often signals how formal the text is. Conversation favours short replies, initial ellipsis and do it/do that. Formal writing favours do so, if so/if not, gapping and the not-forms such as I believe not.
| Informal / spoken | Formal / written |
|---|---|
| 'Will it be ready?' 'Don't think so.' | 'Will the work be completed on time?' 'I believe not.' |
| Want to come? If you do, let me know. | Do you wish to attend? If so, please complete the form. |
| She said she'd fix it and she did it. | She undertook to resolve the issue and did so promptly. |
| 'Has he paid?' 'He might've done.' | It is possible that payment has been made. |
| Some went by bus, some went by train. | Some travelled by bus, others by train. |