1The form: if + past perfect, would have + past participle
A third conditional sentence has two parts. The if-clause (the condition) uses the past perfect: had + past participle. The main clause (the result) uses would have + past participle. Both parts refer to the past, and both are imaginary: they describe the opposite of what really happened. The verb forms are the same for every person — I, you, she, they — so there are no endings to worry about. The only difficulty is remembering the past participles of irregular verbs (gone, seen, known, taken, written, forgotten).
| Third conditional sentence | What really happened |
|---|---|
| If I had known you were ill, I would have visited you. | I didn't know, so I didn't visit you. |
| If she had left earlier, she would have caught the train. | She left late and missed the train. |
| If they had saved more money, they would have bought a bigger flat. | They didn't save enough, so they bought a small flat. |
| If it hadn't rained, we would have had a picnic. | It rained, so we didn't have a picnic. |
| If you hadn't reminded me, I would have forgotten her birthday. | You reminded me, so I remembered. |
Notice how the third conditional turns reality upside down. A positive verb in the sentence means the action did not happen in reality (If I had known = I didn't know). A negative verb means the action did happen (If you hadn't reminded me = you reminded me). This is a useful way to check your understanding: always ask yourself, 'So what really happened?'
2Word order and commas
Like other conditionals, the two clauses can come in either order. The meaning does not change. When the if-clause comes first, we normally put a comma after it. When the main clause comes first, we usually do not use a comma. Starting with the if-clause puts the focus on the condition; starting with the result puts the focus on what would have happened.
- ✓
If we had booked a table, we wouldn't have waited so long.
- ✓
We wouldn't have waited so long if we had booked a table.
- ✓
If he had trained harder, he would have won the race.
- ✓
He would have won the race if he had trained harder.
3Short forms: 'd = had or would?
In speaking and informal writing, both had and would are shortened to 'd. This means a third conditional sentence can have two 'd forms that mean different things: If I'd known, I'd have come. The first 'd is had; the second 'd is would. You can always tell them apart by looking at the next word.
| Next word | 'd means | Example |
|---|---|---|
| a past participle (known, seen, gone) | had | If you'd told me… = If you had told me… |
| have + past participle | would | …I'd have helped. = …I would have helped. |
| a base verb (go, be, like) | would | I'd like a coffee. = I would like… |
| better | had | You'd better hurry. = You had better… |
There is a simple rule: in the if-clause, 'd is always had, because would is not used there. In the main clause, 'd followed by have is always would. In fast speech, would have is often pronounced /ˈwʊdəv/ or even /ˈwʊdə/, and I'd have becomes /aɪdəv/. Because of this pronunciation, some people mistakenly write 'would of' — this is always wrong.
- ✓
If she'd asked me, I'd have said yes. (= If she had asked me, I would have said yes.)
- ✓
We'd have missed the bus if we'd stopped for coffee. (= We would have missed… if we had stopped…)
- ✗
I would of called you.
Write would have (or I'd have), never would of.
4Negative forms
Either clause, or both, can be negative. In the if-clause we use hadn't (had not) + past participle. In the main clause we use wouldn't have (would not have) + past participle. In speech, wouldn't have is often pronounced /ˈwʊdntəv/. Remember the 'reality check': a negative in the sentence means something positive happened in real life.
| Sentence | Reality |
|---|---|
| If I hadn't missed the bus, I wouldn't have been late. | I missed the bus and I was late. |
| If she hadn't helped me, I would have failed. | She helped me and I passed. |
| If we had checked the weather, we wouldn't have gone sailing. | We didn't check and we went sailing. |
| If you hadn't shouted, the baby wouldn't have woken up. | You shouted and the baby woke up. |
5Uses: regrets, criticism, relief and explanations
Because the third conditional is about a past that cannot be changed, we use it to reflect on what happened. It is very common when people talk about mistakes and luck. The same structure can express quite different feelings, depending on the context and the speaker's tone.
| Use | Example |
|---|---|
| Regret (about yourself) | If I had revised more, I would have passed the exam. |
| Criticism (of someone else) | If you had listened to the instructions, you wouldn't have broken it. |
| Relief (something bad nearly happened) | If the lifeguard hadn't seen him, he could have drowned. |
| Explaining a past situation | If the shop had been open, I would have bought some milk. |
| Imagining a different life story | If my parents hadn't moved to Leeds, they would never have met. |
- ✓
If I hadn't eaten so much cake, I wouldn't have felt ill.
- ✓
If you had told me the truth, I wouldn't have been so upset.
- ✓
Thank goodness you called! If you hadn't phoned, I would have driven to the wrong address.
- ✓
If the referee had seen the foul, he would have given a penalty.
- ✓
If Alexander Fleming hadn't noticed the mould, penicillin might not have been discovered so early.
6Could have and might have
In the main clause, would have is not the only option. We can use other modal verbs to change the meaning. Would have means we are sure about the imaginary result. Could have means the result would have been possible, or that someone would have been able to do something. Might have means the result was possible but not certain — perhaps it would have happened, perhaps not.
| Modal | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| would have | certain result | If I'd had a key, I would have opened the door. |
| could have | possible / able to | If I'd had a key, I could have opened the door. |
| might have | perhaps, not sure | If I'd had a key, I might have opened the door. |
- ✓
If you had asked me, I could have lent you my bike. (= I would have been able to lend it.)
- ✓
If we had left at six, we might have avoided the traffic. (= perhaps)
- ✓
If she had applied, she could have got the job. She was the best candidate.
- ✓
If it hadn't been so foggy, we might have seen the mountains.
- ✓
If he hadn't been wearing a helmet, he could have been seriously hurt.
7Without if: but for, otherwise and inversion
At B2 you will also meet third conditional meanings without the word if. The most useful are otherwise (= if not), but for + noun (= if it hadn't been for), and, in formal English, inversion: we drop if and put had before the subject. These forms make your English sound more varied and advanced.
| Structure | Example |
|---|---|
| otherwise | I set two alarms. Otherwise, I would have overslept. |
| if it hadn't been for + noun | If it hadn't been for your help, I would have given up. |
| but for + noun (formal) | But for the rain, the match would have finished on time. |
| Had + subject + past participle (formal) | Had I known, I would have come earlier. (= If I had known) |
| Hadn't / Had … not (formal) | Had she not called, we would have left. (= If she hadn't called) |
8Overview: zero, first, second and third conditionals
English has four main types of conditional. The difference between them is time and reality. Zero and first conditionals talk about real situations: things that are always true or that may really happen. Second and third conditionals talk about unreal, imaginary situations: the second about the present or future, the third about the past. A good way to choose is to ask two questions: When is it? Is it real or imaginary?
| Type | Form | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Zero | if + present simple, present simple | If you heat ice, it melts. |
| First | if + present simple, will + base verb | If it rains tomorrow, we'll stay at home. |
| Second | if + past simple, would + base verb | If I had more time, I would learn Japanese. |
| Third | if + past perfect, would have + past participle | If I had had more time, I would have learnt Japanese. |
| Type | Time | Real or imaginary? |
|---|---|---|
| Zero | always / general truths | real: facts, rules, habits |
| First | the future | real: a possible situation |
| Second | the present or future | imaginary or unlikely |
| Third | the past | imaginary: the opposite of what happened |
- ✓
If I see Tom, I'll give him the message. (first — I may really see him)
- ✓
If I saw a ghost, I would scream. (second — imaginary now)
- ✓
If I had seen Tom yesterday, I would have given him the message. (third — I didn't see him)
9Typical mistakes
Many learners, including speakers of Slavic languages, find the third conditional difficult because their own language often uses the same simple form for imaginary present and imaginary past (in Russian and Ukrainian, a single particle covers both). In English, the time must be shown clearly by the verb forms. Here are the most frequent errors.