1Defining and non-defining: the basic idea
At B1 you met defining relative clauses: The woman who lives next door is a vet. Without the clause, we wouldn't know which woman. A non-defining clause is different. The person or thing is already clear, often because it has a name or a possessive (my mum, our flat, London), and the clause just adds a 'by the way' detail. If you remove a non-defining clause, the sentence still makes complete sense.
Two kinds of relative clause
| Defining | Non-defining |
|---|---|
| tells us which one | adds extra information |
| no commas | commas (or brackets/dashes) around it |
| The man who called was very polite. | Mr Jones, who called this morning, was very polite. |
| can use that | never uses that |
| object pronoun can be left out | pronoun can never be left out |
- ✓
My grandmother, who is 92, still goes swimming every week.
We already know which grandmother I mean — the clause just adds a detail.
- ✓
Edinburgh, which is the capital of Scotland, hosts a huge arts festival every August.
- ✓
Our new teacher, whose husband is a pilot, has travelled all over the world.
- ✓
We stayed at the Grand Hotel, where my parents had their wedding reception.
2The relative pronouns: who, which, whose, where, when
Non-defining clauses use the same relative words as defining clauses, with one important exception: that is not allowed. Choose the pronoun according to what it refers to.
| Pronoun | Refers to | Example |
|---|---|---|
| who | people | Lucy, who works in a bank, gave me some advice. |
| whom | people, as the object (formal) | Mr Patel, whom I met last year, is now the head teacher. |
| which | things, animals, ideas | My laptop, which I bought in May, has already broken. |
| whose | possession (people or things) | Sam, whose sister is a singer, got us free tickets. |
| where | places | Bath, where I grew up, is famous for its Roman baths. |
| when | times | In 2019, when we moved to Bristol, I started a new school. |
- ✓
The Eiffel Tower, which was built in 1889, was meant to be temporary.
- ✓
My aunt, who has lived in Spain for years, speaks Spanish fluently.
- ✓
Our neighbours, whose garden is beautiful, won a local prize.
- ✓
I'll never forget last summer, when we camped in the Lake District.
- ✓
Cornwall, where we spend most holidays, has wonderful beaches.
3No 'that' and no leaving out the pronoun
In defining clauses we can often use that instead of who or which, and we can drop an object pronoun completely (The book I read was great). Neither of these is possible in a non-defining clause. The pronoun must always be there, and it must be who, whom, which, whose, where or when.
- ✓
My phone, which I bought last month, keeps freezing.
- ✗
My phone, that I bought last month, keeps freezing.
No that after a comma → which.
- ✗
My phone, I bought last month, keeps freezing.
The pronoun can't be left out → which I bought.
- ✓
Emma, who you met at the party, is my cousin.
- ✗
Emma, you met at the party, is my cousin.
→ Emma, who (or whom) you met at the party, …
4Commas, and how to say them
In writing, a non-defining clause in the middle of a sentence needs two commas: one before and one after. At the end of a sentence it needs only one comma before it. Forgetting the second comma is a very common mistake. In formal writing you may also see dashes or brackets doing the same job.
- ✓
Mr Brown, who teaches us chemistry, is retiring this year.
middle: two commas
- ✓
We had lunch with Mr Brown, who teaches us chemistry.
end: one comma
- ✗
Mr Brown, who teaches us chemistry is retiring this year.
The second comma is missing.
- ✓
The concert (which lasted four hours) was the highlight of the trip.
Brackets: also possible
5Which referring to a whole clause
A special use of which is to comment on the whole of the previous idea, not just on one noun. This clause always comes at the end of the sentence, after a comma. It often expresses our opinion or a result: annoying, surprising, good news and so on. Only which is possible here — not what, not that, and not it.
- ✓
He arrived an hour late, which annoyed everyone.
which = the fact that he arrived late
- ✓
She passed all her exams, which was a great relief to her parents.
- ✓
The train was cancelled, which meant we had to take a taxi.
- ✓
It rained all weekend, which is typical of a British bank holiday.
- ✗
They didn't reply to my email, what was rather rude.
→ which was rather rude.
- ✗
He failed his driving test again, it was a shame.
Two sentences joined by a comma → which was a shame (or a full stop: … again. It was a shame).
Useful patterns
| Pattern | Example |
|---|---|
| which means / meant (that)… | The shop is closed on Mondays, which means we'll have to go tomorrow. |
| which is why… | I missed the bus, which is why I was late. |
| which surprised / annoyed / pleased … | She remembered my birthday, which really pleased me. |
| which was a pity / a shame / a relief | The match was postponed, which was a pity. |
6Commas change the meaning
Sometimes the same words can form a defining or a non-defining clause, and the commas completely change the meaning. Without commas, the clause tells us which one, so it suggests there are others. With commas, the clause is just extra information about the only one, or about all of them.
| Without commas (defining) | With commas (non-defining) |
|---|---|
| My sister who lives in Paris is a designer. | My sister, who lives in Paris, is a designer. |
| → I have more than one sister; I mean the one in Paris. | → I have only one sister, and by the way, she lives in Paris. |
| The students who had revised passed the test. | The students, who had revised, passed the test. |
| → Only some students revised, and only those passed. | → All the students revised, and all of them passed. |
| The flats which have balconies are more expensive. | The flats, which have balconies, are more expensive. |
| → Only some flats have balconies. | → All the flats have balconies (and they are more expensive than others in the area). |
- ✓
My brother who works in Manchester is coming to visit.
I have at least two brothers.
- ✓
My brother, who works in Manchester, is coming to visit.
I have one brother.
- ✗
My father who is a pilot travels a lot.
You have only one father, so the clause must be non-defining → My father, who is a pilot, travels a lot.
7Prepositions with whom and which (formal)
Many verbs and adjectives are followed by a preposition (talk to, rely on, interested in). In a relative clause, the preposition can go in two places. In everyday English it goes at the end of the clause. In formal English it goes at the beginning, before whom (people) or which (things). After a preposition you must use whom or which — never who or that.
| Informal: preposition at the end | Formal: preposition + whom/which |
|---|---|
| Mrs Clark, who I spoke to yesterday, was very helpful. | Mrs Clark, to whom I spoke yesterday, was very helpful. |
| The report, which we're relying on, is out of date. | The report, on which we are relying, is out of date. |
| My cousins, who I'm staying with, live in York. | My cousins, with whom I am staying, live in York. |
| This project, which I've worked on for months, is nearly finished. | This project, on which I have worked for months, is nearly finished. |
Quantity words + of whom / of which
| Pattern | Example |
|---|---|
| some / many / most of whom | There were 30 applicants, most of whom were very well qualified. |
| all / none / both of which | She wrote three novels, all of which became bestsellers. |
| neither / one / half of whom | He has two brothers, neither of whom lives nearby. |
- ✓
I've got two cousins, both of whom are doctors.
- ✓
We visited several museums, the best of which was the Science Museum.
- ✓
The manager, to whom the letter was addressed, never replied.
- ✗
The manager, to who the letter was addressed, never replied.
After a preposition → whom.
- ✗
I've got two cousins, both of them are doctors.
This joins two sentences with only a comma → both of whom are doctors.
8Where, when and whose in more detail
Where can replace 'in which / at which' for places, and when can replace 'in which / on which' for times. Whose replaces his, her, its or their. Remember that where is only correct if the clause has its own subject and verb; if the place is the subject or object of the clause, use which.
| where / when / whose | Formal alternative |
|---|---|
| Oxford, where she studied, is an hour from London. | Oxford, in which she studied, … |
| 1 May, when the shop opens, is a Saturday. | 1 May, on which the shop opens, … |
| Tom, whose dad is a chef, cooks brilliantly. | (Tom — his dad is a chef — cooks brilliantly.) |
- ✓
We visited York, which has a beautiful cathedral.
York is the subject of 'has' → which
- ✗
We visited York, where has a beautiful cathedral.
The clause needs a subject → which has…
- ✓
We visited York, where we saw the cathedral.
'we' is the subject → where is fine
- ✓
The author, whose latest book won a prize, is giving a talk tonight.
- ✗
The author, who's latest book won a prize, …
who's = who is. Possession → whose.