Eenglish-tests.com
B1

Present Perfect or Past Simple?

Both the Present Perfect and the Past Simple talk about things that happened in the past, so learners often mix them up. The key question is about time: is the time period finished, or does it continue up to now? We use the Past Simple for finished time (I lived in Leeds in 2010) and the Present Perfect for time that is still connected to now (I've lived here for years). At A2 you learnt the basics with ever, just, already and yet. On this page we look more deeply at time words, news stories, been and gone, and the mistakes that even good students still make.

1A quick review of the two forms

The Past Simple is one word in positive sentences (worked, went, saw) and uses did in questions and negatives. The Present Perfect always has two parts: have / has + past participle (have worked, has gone, have seen). Remember that for many irregular verbs the past participle is different from the Past Simple form.

Past SimplePresent Perfect
PositiveShe visited Rome.She's visited Rome.
NegativeShe didn't visit Rome.She hasn't visited Rome.
QuestionDid she visit Rome?Has she visited Rome?
IrregularI saw it. / We went.I've seen it. / We've gone.
Past Simple: subject + verb-ed / past form · Present Perfect: subject + have / has + past participle

2The main idea: finished or unfinished time

English speakers choose the tense by looking at the time period, not only at the action. If the action happened in a period that is over — yesterday, last summer, in 2015, when I was a child — we use the Past Simple. If the period is not finished — today, this week, my life, since Monday — or if we don't mention any time at all and think about the present, we use the Present Perfect.

Finished time → Past SimpleUnfinished time → Present Perfect
I wrote three emails yesterday.I've written three emails today.
We didn't see much sun last month.We haven't seen much sun this month.
He worked in a bank for ten years. (He doesn't now.)He's worked in a bank for ten years. (He still does.)
Shakespeare wrote 39 plays.My sister has written two books.

Look at the last line. Shakespeare is dead, so his life is a finished period and we use the Past Simple. My sister is alive and may write more books, so her life is an unfinished period and we use the Present Perfect. The same logic explains why we say I lived in Paris for three years (I don't live there any more) but I've lived in London for three years (I still live there).

  • ✓

    I've had this bike since I was twelve. (I still have it.)

  • ✓

    I had a red bike when I was twelve. (I don't have it now.)

  • ✓

    Have you seen Tom this morning? (said at 10 a.m. — the morning isn't over)

  • ✓

    Did you see Tom this morning? (said at 4 p.m. — the morning is over)

3Time words: which tense do they go with?

Time words are the best clue. Some always point to a finished time and need the Past Simple. Others point to a period that reaches now and usually go with the Present Perfect. A few, like today and this week, can go with both, depending on whether we see the period as still open.

Time words

Past Simple (finished time)Present Perfect (up to now)
yesterday, the day before yesterdayever, never
last night / week / yearjust, already, yet
two days ago, a long time agoso far, up to now, until now
in 2010, in May, on Fridayrecently, lately
at three o'clock, last weekendtoday, this week, this year (still going on)
when I was young, then, after thatfor… / since… (period up to now)
  • ✓

    I finished the book two days ago.

  • ✓

    So far I've read half of the book.

  • ✓

    We moved to Bristol in 2019.

  • ✓

    Have you been to any concerts recently?

  • ✓

    She called me last night.

  • ✓

    She hasn't called me this week.

4Specific time or no time?

When the exact time is important, or the listener wants to know it, we need the Past Simple. When the time is unknown, unimportant or simply 'some time before now', we use the Present Perfect. That is why questions with When…? and What time…? are always in the Past Simple — they ask about a specific time.

No time / time not importantA specific time
I've lost my wallet.I lost it on the bus this morning.
Someone has eaten my sandwich!Who ate it? When did it happen?
They've bought a new house.They bought it in March.

5News: the headline and the details

When we give news, we often start with the Present Perfect. It gives the main fact, which is new and important now. Then, when we add details — when, where, how, who — we change to the Past Simple, because now we are talking about a specific finished event. You can hear this pattern every day on the radio, on TV and in conversations with friends.

  • ✓

    A lorry has crashed on the M25. It happened at about six o'clock this morning, and the driver was taken to hospital.

  • ✓

    Guess what? I've passed my driving test! I took it on Tuesday and the examiner said I drove really well.

  • ✓

    Scientists have discovered a new kind of frog. They found it in a forest in Peru last year.

  • ✓

    Oh no, I've broken my glasses. I dropped them on the floor when I got out of bed.

StepTenseExample
1. The newsPresent PerfectOur cat has had kittens!
2. The detailsPast SimpleShe had them last night in the cupboard.
3. More detailsPast SimpleWe found them this morning. There were five!

6Experience questions and follow-up questions

Conversations about experience follow the same pattern. The first question asks about life up to now (Present Perfect with ever). If the answer is yes, the next questions ask about that particular time (Past Simple). Notice how the speakers switch tense naturally.

  • ✓

    A: Have you ever tried surfing?

  • ✓

    B: Yes, I have. I tried it in Cornwall two summers ago.

  • ✓

    A: Did you like it?

  • ✓

    B: I loved it, but I fell into the water about fifty times!

General experience (Present Perfect)Follow-up (Past Simple)
Have you ever met a famous person?Who was it? Where did you meet them?
Has she ever won a prize?What did she win it for?
I've been to Iceland.Really? When did you go? Was it cold?

7Been or gone?

In the Present Perfect, we can talk about going somewhere with two different participles: gone (from go) and been (from be). Gone means the person went and is still away (or on the way). Been means the person went and came back — it is a visit or an experience. In the Past Simple there is no such difference: we just use went.

SentenceWhere is the person now?
Dad has gone to the supermarket.At the supermarket or on his way — not at home.
Dad has been to the supermarket.Back at home with the shopping.
Mia has gone to Canada for a year.She is in Canada now.
Mia has been to Canada twice.She visited it twice in her life; now she isn't there.
Mia went to Canada last year.Past Simple: we only know the trip happened.
  • ✓

    Where's Jack? — He's gone to football practice. He'll be back at six.

  • ✓

    You look tired. — Yes, I've been to the gym.

  • ✓

    I've never been to a music festival.

8Results now or a finished story?

Sometimes no time word is given, and both tenses are grammatically possible. Then the choice depends on what you want to say. Use the Present Perfect when you are thinking about the result now. Use the Past Simple when you are telling a story or thinking about the past situation itself.

Present Perfect: result nowPast Simple: past event
I've cut my finger. (Look — it's bleeding!)I cut my finger while I was cooking. (telling the story)
Someone has opened the window. (It's cold in here now.)Someone opened the window and then closed it again.
He's left his job. (He hasn't got a job now.)He left his job and started a business.

9Typical mistakes

Many languages, including Russian and Ukrainian, use one past tense for all of these situations, so learners often choose the tense by the action and not by the time period. Check the time words in the sentence first.

Present Perfect or Past Simple?: tests

2 free tests and 8 Premium tests.

GameFix the mistake: Present Perfect or Past Simple?Find the mistake in each sentence and choose the right word.Play →

Found this lesson useful? Share it with a friend or your class.