1Making guesses: what is a modal of possibility?
Very often we talk about things we cannot see or check. Where is Tom? Why is the baby crying? Who is at the door? We don't know the answer for sure, so we make a guess (in grammar books this is called deduction or speculation). The modal verb tells the listener how sure we are. We choose the modal because of the evidence — the facts that we can see, hear or know.
- ✓
The lights are on. They must be at home.
Strong evidence — I'm almost sure it's true.
- ✓
I'm not sure where Anna is. She might be at the gym.
Little evidence — it's just possible.
- ✓
That can't be Jack. Jack is in Spain this week.
Strong evidence — I'm almost sure it isn't true.
All these modals work in the same simple way. They have one form for every person (no -s), there is no to after them, and the next verb is in the base form. When we talk about the present, the verb after the modal is very often be.
2The certainty scale
It helps to imagine a line from 100% (I know it's true) to 0% (I know it isn't true). When we know a fact, we don't need a modal at all — we just use the normal verb: She is at home. She isn't at home. The modals go in between.
How sure are you?
| How sure? | Example |
|---|---|
| 100% — a fact | She is at home. (I can see her.) |
| about 90% — almost sure it's true | She must be at home. (Her bike is outside.) |
| about 50% — possible | She may / might / could be at home. (I don't know.) |
| about 50% — possibly not | She may not / might not be at home. |
| about 90% — almost sure it isn't true | She can't be at home. (I saw her at the station a minute ago.) |
| 100% — a fact | She isn't at home. (She's here at school with me.) |
3must: I'm almost sure it's true
We use must when we have good evidence and we feel almost certain. It is a logical conclusion: we look at the facts and think 'this is the only explanation'. We don't use must when we are only guessing without evidence.
| Evidence | Conclusion |
|---|---|
| He has worked for twelve hours. | He must be exhausted. |
| Everyone is wearing coats and scarves. | It must be cold outside. |
| She speaks Spanish, French and German. | She must be good at languages. |
| You've just won the competition! | You must be very happy. |
| The restaurant is always full. | The food must be good. |
| There's a long queue outside the cinema. | It must be a popular film. |
- ✓
You've been travelling all day. You must be hungry.
- ✓
Someone is knocking. That must be the delivery driver.
- ✓
Her phone is switched off. She must be in the meeting.
- ✓
This must be your bag — it's got your name on it.
4can't: I'm almost sure it's impossible
The negative of must for guesses is can't (or the more formal cannot), NOT mustn't. We use can't when the evidence tells us that something is impossible. We also use couldn't in the same way: It couldn't be true!
| Evidence | Conclusion |
|---|---|
| He has just eaten a huge pizza. | He can't be hungry. |
| She's only fourteen. | She can't be a university student. |
| The shop opens at nine and it's eight o'clock. | It can't be open yet. |
| You've only been here for ten minutes. | You can't be tired already! |
| That watch costs £5. | It can't be real gold. |
- ✓
That can't be Mr Lee. He's on holiday in Scotland.
- ✓
You can't be serious! Ten pounds for a cup of tea?
- ✓
This can't be the right address. There's no house here.
- ✓
That's my umbrella. — It can't be yours. Yours is red, and this one is blue.
5may, might and could: it's possible
When we have some ideas but no strong evidence, we use may, might or could. They all mean 'perhaps' or 'maybe' — about 50% sure. In everyday speech they mean almost the same. Might is the most common in conversation; may is a little more formal; could often suggests one possible explanation among several.
- ✓
Where's Sam? — I'm not sure. He might be in the garden.
- ✓
Don't eat those mushrooms. They may be poisonous.
- ✓
Who's that at the door? — It could be the postman, or it could be Grandma.
- ✓
Take an umbrella. It might rain later.
We also use might and may for the future.
- ✓
This answer may be wrong. Let's check it again.
- ✓
Ask Emma. She might know the answer.
Different ways to say the same thing
| With maybe / perhaps | With a modal |
|---|---|
| Maybe she's at work. | She might be at work. |
| Perhaps it's true. | It may be true. |
| Maybe they're lost. | They could be lost. |
6may not and might not vs can't
Be careful with the negatives. may not and might not (short form mightn't, which is less common) mean 'perhaps not' — it's possible that something isn't true. can't means 'I'm sure it isn't true'. They are very different in strength.
| Sentence | Meaning |
|---|---|
| He might not be at home. | Perhaps he isn't at home. I'm not sure. |
| He may not be at home. | The same, a little more formal. |
| He can't be at home. | I'm sure he isn't at home — I've just seen him in town. |
Another important point: could not / couldn't is NOT the same as might not. Couldn't is strong, like can't. So for 'perhaps not', use may not or might not, never couldn't.
- ✓
Call before you go. The museum might not be open on Mondays.
Perhaps it's closed.
- ✓
The museum can't be open. It's three o'clock in the morning!
I'm sure it's closed.
- ✓
She couldn't be the new teacher — she's only sixteen!
couldn't = can't, impossible.
- ✓
She may not know about the party. Let's tell her.
Perhaps she doesn't know.
7Continuous forms: She might be sleeping
Sometimes we want to guess what someone is doing right now, at this moment. Then we use the modal + be + the -ing form of the verb. This is like the Present Continuous (she is sleeping), but with a modal instead of am/is/are.
| Fact (Present Continuous) | Guess (modal + be + -ing) |
|---|---|
| She is sleeping. | She might be sleeping. Don't call her now. |
| They are having dinner. | They must be having dinner. I can smell cooking. |
| He isn't working today. | He can't be working today. It's Sunday and his office is closed. |
| It is raining. | It could be raining in the mountains. |
- ✓
Jo isn't answering the phone. She may be driving.
- ✓
The children are very quiet. They must be watching a film.
- ✓
You can't be doing your homework — your book is closed!
- ✓
Listen to that noise! The neighbours might be building something.
8Questions: Could it be…?
To ask about possibility, we usually use could or might (more formal) before the subject. We don't use may in questions about possibility — it sounds like asking for permission (May I…?). We don't use must or can't in these questions either. Very often we ask with Do you think…? + a normal sentence or a modal.
| Question | Possible answer |
|---|---|
| Could it be a mistake? | Yes, it could. Let's check. |
| Could they be lost? | They might be. They don't know the town. |
| Who could that be? | It might be Lucy. She said she would come. |
| Where could my keys be? | They could be in your coat pocket. |
| Do you think he's ill? | He might be. He looked pale yesterday. |
| Can it really be true? | No, it can't be. It's just a rumour. |
9Two meanings of must
At A2 you learnt must for obligation and rules: You must wear a seatbelt. On this page, must means something different: I'm almost sure. The form is the same, so we understand the meaning from the context. Usually, must for certainty is followed by be (or be + -ing) and refers to a situation we can't see; must for obligation is followed by an action verb and talks about rules or what is necessary.
| must = I'm sure (certainty) | must = it's necessary (obligation) |
|---|---|
| You must be tired after your long journey. | You must go to bed now — it's late. |
| He must be a doctor. He's wearing a white coat. | Doctors must wash their hands often. |
| This must be the right room. | You must be in the room by nine o'clock. |
The negatives are also different. For certainty, the opposite is can't (it's impossible). For obligation, the negative is mustn't (it's not allowed) or don't have to (it's not necessary).
| Meaning | Negative |
|---|---|
| certainty: She must be ill. | She can't be ill. (I'm sure she isn't.) |
| obligation: You must stay here. | You mustn't leave. (It's not allowed.) |