1Four words, three meanings
Before we look at each verb, here is the big picture. There are three different ideas: something is necessary, something is not allowed, and something is not necessary. Learn this table first — the rest of the page explains it.
| Words | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| must / have to | It is necessary. Do it! | You must / have to show your passport at the airport. |
| mustn't | It is not allowed. Don't do it! | You mustn't use your phone in the exam. |
| don't have to | It is not necessary. You can if you want. | You don't have to come. It's your choice. |
2Must: form
Must is a modal verb, like can and will. It has only one form for all subjects: no -s with he, she and it, and no to after it. The negative is must not, usually shortened to mustn't /ˈmʌsnt/ (the first t is silent).
| Positive | Negative |
|---|---|
| I must go. | I mustn't be late. |
| She must study. | She mustn't forget. |
| We must hurry. | We mustn't make a noise. |
3Must: when do we use it?
We use must in two main situations. First, in written rules and laws — on signs, notices, instructions and in school rules. Second, when the speaker feels that something is very important — the obligation comes from the person who is talking: I must call my grandma (I think it's important). Must sounds strong and serious.
| Situation | Example |
|---|---|
| A sign or notice | Visitors must report to reception. |
| School rules | Students must wear a uniform. |
| Instructions | You must answer all the questions. |
| My own strong feeling | I must go to bed earlier. I'm always tired. |
| Strong advice to a friend | You must see this film. It's fantastic! |
- ✓
Passengers must keep their bags with them.
- ✓
I must remember to buy Mum a birthday card.
- ✓
We must visit you in Manchester soon!
- ✓
You must try this cake. It's delicious.
4Have to: form
Have to is not a modal verb. It works like an ordinary verb in the Present Simple: has to with he, she and it, and do / does in negatives and questions. Pronunciation tip: we usually say /ˈhæftə/ and /ˈhæstə/.
| I / you / we / they | he / she / it | |
|---|---|---|
| Positive | I have to work. | She has to work. |
| Negative | I don't have to work. | She doesn't have to work. |
| Question | Do you have to work? | Does she have to work? |
| Short answers | Yes, I do. / No, I don't. | Yes, she does. / No, she doesn't. |
5Have to: when do we use it?
We use have to when the obligation comes from outside — from a rule, a law, a boss, a teacher, a timetable or the situation. It's not my idea, but I have no choice. Have to is also the normal, everyday way to talk about duties and routines.
- ✓
I have to wear a uniform at school.
It's the school's rule.
- ✓
My dad has to start work at seven.
His boss says so.
- ✓
We have to change trains in Birmingham.
The train doesn't go all the way.
- ✓
In the UK you have to drive on the left.
- ✓
I can't come out tonight. I have to look after my little sister.
6Must or have to?
In positive sentences, must and have to are often both possible, and the difference is small. Must = I (the speaker) think it is necessary. Have to = someone or something else makes it necessary. In conversation, British people use have to more often, because must can sound very strong or formal.
| must (the speaker decides) | have to (an outside rule) |
|---|---|
| I must do more exercise. (I want to be fit.) | I have to do PE on Tuesdays. (It's on the timetable.) |
| I must clean my room. It's so messy! | I have to clean my room. Mum says so. |
| You must come to my party! (I really want you there.) | You have to be eighteen to vote. (It's the law.) |
7Mustn't or don't have to? The key difference
This is the most important part of the topic, and a very common mistake. In positive sentences must and have to are similar, but their negatives mean completely different things. Mustn't = it is not allowed, it's prohibited, don't do it. Don't have to = it isn't necessary, there's no obligation, but you can do it if you want.
| mustn't = not allowed | don't have to = not necessary |
|---|---|
| You mustn't run by the pool. (It's dangerous — don't!) | You don't have to swim today. (You can just sit if you want.) |
| You mustn't eat in the library. | You don't have to bring food. We have sandwiches. |
| You mustn't tell anyone. It's a secret! | You don't have to tell me. I already know. |
| Students mustn't use dictionaries in the test. | Students don't have to wear a uniform on Fridays. |
| We mustn't be late for the exam. | We don't have to get up early. It's Sunday! |
| You mustn't drive without a licence. | She doesn't have to work tomorrow. It's a holiday. |
- ✓
You mustn't touch that. It's hot!
- ✓
You don't have to pay. It's free.
- ✓
My brother doesn't have to do homework at the weekend, but he often does.
- ✓
You mustn't cross the road when the light is red.
8Questions: Do I have to…?
To ask if something is necessary, we usually say Do I have to…? or Does he have to…? Questions with Must I…? are possible but sound formal and old-fashioned, so they are not common in everyday English.
- ✓
Do I have to wear a tie? — No, you don't.
- ✓
Does she have to take the exam again? — Yes, she does.
- ✓
What time do you have to be at school?
- ✓
Why do we have to do this exercise?
- ✓
How many hours does your mum have to work?
9The past: had to
Must has no past form. For obligation in the past, we use had to for all subjects. In negatives and questions we use did: didn't have to, Did you have to…?
- ✓
Yesterday I had to stay at school until five.
- ✓
When my grandad was young, he had to walk to school.
- ✓
We didn't have to wait long for the bus.
- ✓
Did you have to pay for the tickets? — No, we didn't.
10The future: will have to
For obligation in the future, we often use will have to ('ll have to) and won't have to. We can't say ✗ will must.
- ✓
You'll have to get up early tomorrow. The bus leaves at seven.
- ✓
If you lose the ticket, you'll have to buy a new one.
- ✓
When I finish school, I won't have to wear a uniform.
- ✓
Will we have to take a test?
Have to in different times
| Time | Positive | Negative |
|---|---|---|
| Past | I had to work. | I didn't have to work. |
| Present | I have to work. | I don't have to work. |
| Future | I'll have to work. | I won't have to work. |